Welcome to the House of Pitching Newsletter.
Each month I’m sent dozens of ideas for newsletter topics. Most are pretty good and I have ever desire to write about that topic but, with only doing 1 newsletter per month, it’s hard to know which topic is best. So, I try to pick the most common question asked during a month time frame. This month’s most common theme was involving other pitching instructors. However, I’m just not in the mood today to go into The Pitching Coach Mafia and all their stuff. It’s depressing to me. I’ve got all kinds of stories I could share about PCM people, maybe I should write a book of them. I’d have to enter witness protection after doing it but, it may be worth it. After all Sammy the Bull wrote a book while in the Witness Protection program. But, like Sammy the Bull Gravano, I’d probably find myself in trouble again with the very people I’m trying to hide from as I continue to see what gets taught. Remember that story I told a year or so ago about the PCM guy who would ban you from his website forum if you mentioned my name? Well there’s a better one from a PCM’er in Cleveland who insisted to a student of mine that unless she changes her motion from pitch to pitch (stepping short/long, side to side) then there is no way to make the ball go high/low or to the sides. I’m amazed to hear all along, despite the pitching career I’ve had and continue to have that I cannot make the ball go high or low doing it the way I do. Imagine my surprise to learn this! I guess all this time, I’ve been throwing pitches right down the middle and unable to make it move doing it the way I do. You know it’s genius’s like that PCM member who are wasting their intellect and brains with softball. We need that person to solve the Israeli-Palestine conflict where they can put their superior brains into action for the good of humanity.
That just goes to show you the flaw in society. You need a license to go catch a fish but no credential or brains to teach someone how to pitch. Something is wrong with that.
One thing I’m also amazed at is how many pitchers don’t take their personal catcher to pitching practice. I know that schedules are sometimes tough to coordinate but, whenever possible, I would insist on this if I was a coach or parent of a successful pitcher. The catcher is the unsung hero for a pitcher and like a good umpire, you only realize a catcher when they do something wrong. Sad but true. Think about it.. good umpires don’t want to be seen on the field. They want to make the call and let the game go. Catchers are involved in every pitch, same as the pitcher but only get ‘seen’ when they do something heroic or bad. When a pitcher throws a great game, it’s not often that the catcher is complimented. And there is always that friendly rivalry between pitchers and catchers but, the truth is they need each other. A good catcher looks bad without a good pitcher and vice versa.
One of my pet peeves in the sport is coaches who call pitches for their battery. For some reason this is most common in softball rather than baseball and I don’t get why. For whatever reason, coaches don’t teach pitchers/catchers what to look for in a hitter or situation. They don’t teach them to hone their instincts. Instead, they just teach the mechanics of catching without the mental side of it. I guarantee you there is no 2 people on that field who understand the situation better than the pitcher and catcher, but you have to teach them how to react and respond to everything. It doesn’t come naturally. In my opinion, coaches calling pitches is a microcosm of society at large today. Everyone wants things done for them instead of doing it themselves. Instead of exercise, take a diet pill, etc.
Girls can be taught, the same as boys can about what pitches are appropriate and when. The catcher needs to be taught what to look for, how to remember the hitter’s last at bat, what the umpire’s zone is, how to talk to the umpire between pitches/innings, and how to set up one pitch to help the next. It’s so sexist and down right stupid to think girls cannot learn this. And it can begin at pitching practice with a quality pitching coach who can teach the rules of thumb about what to throw and when. It’s not an exact science. Catchers will get it wrong, so will coaches. Besides, regardless of who’s calling the pitch, the pitcher has to throw the ball where it’s called anyway. And that pitcher should have veto power over everyone! Yes, coaches, that means you too! The pitcher knows if the ball is slick, if the rubber is crooked or muddy, if the seams are to high/low on the ball, if it feels heavy, etc. THEY KNOW THIS, NOT YOU. From personal experience, nothing is worse than throwing a pitch, watching it get smacked and KNOWING I shouldn’t have thrown THAT pitch. Even if it’s the right call, the pitcher has to feel right about that pitch. This is when pre-game meetings and between inning talks come into play. Discussing how to attack the hitters will play a role in what is the best pitch to throw.
It’s troubling to admit but, good catchers are hard to find. It’s because we aren’t teaching the catchers anymore, we’re just showing them. This is how you catch the ball but depriving them of how to think for themselves and for the pitcher is an aspect of the game becoming extinct quicker than we realize.
I lovingly call catchers a necessary evil. But the truth is, they can be a pitchers best friend or worst enemy. Why do you think most catchers LOVE the Bull Durham movie? It wasn’t for the fine acting by Costner or to see Tim Robbins in his underwear. It was because it showed a catcher TUTORING a pitcher on how to be great. Of course, they left out of the movie that it was probably a pitcher who originally taught the catcher!!!!!!!!!!!